Kanazawa Castle Park: Complete 6-Area Visitor Guide (Personally Visited)

Kanazawa Castle Park is one of Japan’s most rewarding free-entry castle sites — and one of the most misunderstood. Most visitors spend 45 minutes walking between the obvious photo spots. This guide, based on a personal visit covering all six areas, gives you what other guides skip: which structures are genuinely from the Edo period and which were rebuilt in the 2000s, which paid areas are worth the ¥320 fee, and the stonework details that make Kanazawa Castle architecturally unique among Japanese castles.

Kanazawa Castle is a magnificent fortress and a symbol of the prosperous Kaga Domain, once ruled by the powerful Maeda clan for nearly 300 years — from the late Sengoku period through the Meiji Restoration. Along with Kenrokuen Garden, it stands as one of Kanazawa’s most iconic attractions. Its gleaming white plaster walls and lead-tiled roofs have earned it the nickname “The White Castle.”

✓ Personally Visited Guide — October 2025

This guide is based on a personal visit to all six areas of Kanazawa Castle Park in October 2025. Every structure, stonework technique, and practical detail described here — from Ishikawa-mon Gate through to Gyokusen’inmaru Garden — was confirmed on-site. Admission fees, opening hours, and access routes are included as observed during the visit.

Official name Kanazawa Castle Park (Kanazawa-jo Ato — Nationally Designated Historic Site)
Address 1-1 Marunouchi, Kanazawa, Ishikawa 920-0937
Admission Grounds (outer enclosure, Sannomaru, Honmaru): Free
Hishi Yagura · Gojikken Nagaya interior: ¥320 adults / ¥100 children
Gyokusen’inmaru Garden: ¥320 adults (separate admission)
Hours 7:00–18:00 (Mar 1 – Oct 15) / 8:00–17:00 (Oct 16 – Feb)
Inner buildings: 9:00–16:30 (last entry 16:00)
※ Extended during night illumination events
Closed Grounds: Open year-round / Inner buildings: Dec 29–Jan 3
Recommended time Highlights only: 45–60 min / Full 6-area route: 90–120 min
Combined with Kenrokuen Garden: half day to full day
Access From Kanazawa Station East Exit — Kanazawa Loop Bus or Kenrokuen Shuttle
Approx. 20 min to Kanazawa Castle / Kenrokuen-shita stop
Hokuriku Shinkansen from Tokyo Station: approx. 2 hr 30 min
Parking No dedicated parking inside the park.
Use Kenrokuen Parking or Kanazawa Castle Park North Parking (both paid)
Official info Kanazawa Castle Park — Official Site (English)

What Makes Kanazawa Castle Different from Other Japanese Castles

Hishi Yagura and Gojikken Nagaya — the white lead-tiled roofs that give Kanazawa Castle its distinctive appearance
Hishi Yagura — the white lead-tiled roofs, distinctive to Kanazawa Castle

Most visitors to Japan’s famous castles — Himeji, Matsumoto, Osaka — encounter a single dominant keep rising above the grounds. Kanazawa Castle has no surviving keep. What it offers instead is something rarer: a castle site where three distinct historical layers — Edo-period originals, Meiji military architecture, and modern reconstructions — exist side by side on a single walkable loop.

Three features set Kanazawa Castle apart architecturally. First, the stone masonry diversity: on the same walking route, you will encounter rough Nozurazumi stacking (near Ishikawa-mon), precision-fit Kirikomi-hagi (along the Kahoku-mon approach), and hexagonal Kikko-ishi (at the Ninomaru walls). No other castle in Japan displays all three techniques in such close proximity. Second, the lead-tiled roofs — a signature of the Maeda clan’s wealth and the reason the castle complex appears white rather than grey from a distance. Third, the free entry to the grounds: unlike most reconstructed Japanese castles, the majority of Kanazawa Castle Park is open at no charge.

Historical Overview of Kanazawa Castle

The origins of Kanazawa Castle trace back to the 1480s during Japan’s Warring States period, when the followers of Honganji Temple built a fortified religious complex known as Kanazawa Mido. The city flourished as a center of the Kaga Ikko-ikki uprising, a self-governed religious community. However, in 1580, it fell to Sakuma Morimasa, a general serving under Oda Nobunaga. Three years later, in 1583, Maeda Toshiie took control of the castle and began ruling over the provinces of Kaga, Noto, and Etchu.

Under the Maeda clan, Kanazawa Castle evolved into both a political center and a family residence. The Maeda were the wealthiest domain outside the Tokugawa shogunate — with a nominal income of one million koku — yet they avoided conflict with Edo for nearly 270 years through careful diplomacy, cultural patronage, and strategic marriages. Extensive improvements were made over time: moats, stone walls, and long storehouses were expanded, and by the early Edo period, the Ninomaru, Honmaru, and Gyokusen’inmaru areas were completed. At its height, the castle complex covered roughly 250,000 square meters and boasted over 30 towers and gates.

After the Meiji Restoration, the castle grounds were repurposed for military use, housing the Kanazawa Garrison and later the headquarters of the 6th Brigade of the Imperial Japanese Army. Following World War II, the site became the campus of Kanazawa University. When the university relocated in the 1990s, Ishikawa Prefecture launched an ambitious restoration project, reconstructing the Kahoku-mon Gate (2010), Hishi Yagura and Gojikken Nagaya (2001), and the Nezumitamon Bridge (2020). Today, Kanazawa Castle is open to the public as a nationally designated historic site.

Beyond its gates and turrets, the castle’s charm lies in its diverse stone masonry techniques — including the precision-cut “Kirikomi-hagi,” hexagonal “Kikko-ishi,” and the elegant “Shikishi-tanzaku-zumi.” Visitors can also enjoy the serene waterscape of Gyokusen’inmaru Garden and the enchanting nighttime illumination that highlights the castle’s architectural beauty.

Warring States 1480s–1580
  • Honganji followers build Kanazawa Mido
  • Kaga Ikko-ikki self-governance
  • 1580: Falls to Sakuma Morimasa
Edo Period 1583–1868
  • 1583: Maeda Toshiie takes the castle
  • Moats, stone walls & storehouses expanded
  • Peak: ~250,000 m², 30+ towers & gates
Meiji–Showa 1868–1990s
  • Imperial Army 6th Brigade HQ
  • Post-war: Kanazawa University campus
  • 1990s: University relocates; restoration begins
Heisei–Reiwa 2001–present
  • 2001: Hishi Yagura & Nagaya reconstructed
  • 2010: Kahoku-mon Gate reconstructed
  • 2020: Nezumita-mon & Bridge reconstructed

Original vs. Reconstructed: What Survives from the Edo Period

One question most guides skip over: which structures at Kanazawa Castle are genuinely from the Edo period, and which were rebuilt in modern times? Here is a straightforward summary based on a personal visit and on the historical records displayed on site.

Structure Status Notes
Ishikawa-mon Gate Original — rebuilt 1788, survives intact National Important Cultural Property. One of the few Edo-period structures still standing in the castle park.
Tsurumaru Warehouse Original — 19th century, survives intact Designated cultural property. A rare surviving example of castle storage architecture.
Former 6th Brigade HQ Original — Meiji era, survives intact Designated cultural property. A visible record of the castle’s military-era repurposing.
Hishi Yagura + Gojikken Nagaya Reconstructed 2001 Built based on historical records and surviving architectural drawings. Interiors open to visitors (fee).
Sanjikken Nagaya Reconstructed 2001 Part of the same restoration project as Hishi Yagura.
Kahoku-mon Gate Reconstructed 2010 Reconstructed as the main front gateway. Connects Sannomaru to the inner castle.
Nezumita-mon Gate & Bridge Reconstructed 2020 The most recent reconstruction. Re-establishes the western pedestrian link toward Oyama Shrine.
Gyokusen’inmaru Garden Restored 2015 Restored based on historical records of the Maeda lords’ garden. Admission fee applies.

Key takeaway: Of the structures you’ll walk past on the standard route, only Ishikawa-mon Gate and the Tsurumaru Warehouse are genuine Edo-period survivors. The dramatic Hishi Yagura and Kahoku-mon — while impressive — are both modern reconstructions. If seeing authentic Edo architecture is your priority, Ishikawa-mon and the Tsurumaru Warehouse are the structures to linger at.

Access to Kanazawa Castle Park

From JR Tokyo Station, take the Hokuriku Shinkansen to JR Kanazawa Station (approx. 2 hours 30 minutes). From Kanazawa Station, several buses reach the castle area in about 20 minutes.

Getting There — Train, Bus & Car

Main access routes to Kanazawa Castle Park.

From Tokyo Tokyo Station → Hokuriku Shinkansen (Kagayaki / Hakutaka) → Kanazawa Station: approx. 2 hr 30 min
From Osaka Shin-Osaka → Thunderbird → Kanazawa Station: approx. 2 hr 15 min (transfer at Tsuruga since Mar 2024)
From Kanazawa Station East Exit (Kenrokuen-guchi) bus stops → Hokuriku Tetsu-do Bus / West JR Bus
Kanazawa Castle / Kenrokuen-shita stop → walk 2 min (approx. 20 min / from ¥210)
Kanazawa Loop Bus “Shitamachi Kanazawa Shuyu” also available (1-day pass available)
On foot Approx. 25–30 min walk from Kanazawa Station East Exit (flat route)
By car Approx. 10 min from Kanazawa Higashi IC (Hokuriku Expressway)
No dedicated parking inside the park — use Kenrokuen Parking or Kanazawa Castle Park North Parking (both paid)

Recommended bus stop: Kanazawa Castle / Kenrokuen-shita — a short walk to Ishikawa-mon Gate, the classic starting point for the castle walk. From the East Exit of Kanazawa Station, take the Kanazawa Loop Bus (clockwise or counterclockwise) or the Kenrokuen Shuttle. IC cards (Suica, ICOCA) are accepted on most routes.

By car: Parking is available at the Kenrokuen parking areas nearby. Driving is practical if arriving from outside Kanazawa, but buses are more convenient from Kanazawa Station.

Entry & hours at a glance:
·Grounds (free): Open 7:00–18:00 (Mar–Oct) / 8:00–17:00 (Nov–Feb)
·Inner buildings (Hishi Yagura, Nagaya, Gyokusen’inmaru Garden): ¥320 adults / 9:00–16:30 (last entry 16:00)
·Closed: December 29–31
* Confirm current hours at the Ishikawa Prefecture official page before visiting.


Quick Guide: Top 7 Must-See Spots

Perfect for travelers short on time — this curated guide highlights the seven essential spots to experience the essence of Kanazawa Castle.

Kanazawa Castle in 1 Hour: 7 Must-See Spots with 360° Panoramas & Route Map
Short on time in Kanazawa? This 1-hour model route covers the 7 essential castle highlights — from Ishikawa-mon to Nezumitamon Bridge — with exclusive 360° panoramas at every stop.

Complete Guide: Explore Kanazawa Castle Through Six Distinct Areas

Kanazawa Castle combines history, architecture, and scenic beauty, making it one of Japan’s most comprehensive and captivating castle sites. In the following sections, we explore the castle grounds divided into six key areas, based on their geography and walking routes.

The classic walking route starts at the Ishikawa-mon Gate, moves through the Sannomaru, Ninomaru, and Honmaru, then exits via the Gyokusen’inmaru Garden. In the six area guides below, we highlight the best sights in the order you’ll encounter them.

AREA 01 | Rear Approach / Ishikawa-mon Gate

Rear Approach / Ishikawa-mon Gate (Karame-te)

Enter from the Kenrokuen side via the castle’s rear karame-te (back gate) approach. The Edo-period Ishikawa-mon Gate, its masugata defensive layout, and the open Sannomaru North Garden are the highlights.

Visitor’s note: Ishikawa-mon is the one structure in the entire park that genuinely dates from the Edo period — rebuilt in 1788 and still standing. Most visitors walk through it quickly, but it’s worth pausing inside the masugata courtyard. The stone walls here show the “Nozurazumi” (rough-stacked) technique that predates the later precision-cut styles deeper in the park — the contrast becomes much more visible once you know to look for it.
Kanazawa Castle Vol. 1: Ishikawa-mon Gate & Sannomaru North Garden — Edo-Period Original in 360°
Ishikawa-mon Gate — rebuilt 1788, the only surviving Edo-period gate at Kanazawa Castle. Explore the masugata courtyard, Nozurazumi stonework, and Sannomaru North Garden with 360° panoramas.
AREA 02 | Sannomaru & Main Entrance

Sannomaru & Main Entrance (Kahoku-mon, Hashizume-mon & Plaza)

This is the castle’s front gateway. The line from Kahoku-mon to Hashizume-mon concentrates major reconstructions, giving you a vivid sense of Kanazawa Castle’s scale and defensive structure.

Visitor’s note: Kahoku-mon (2010 reconstruction) and the Sannomaru Plaza in front of it give a strong impression of the castle’s intended grandeur. The stone walls flanking the approach show the “Kirikomi-hagi” (precision-cut) technique — each stone shaped to fit exactly against its neighbors. Run your hand along the joint and there’s almost no gap. It’s a noticeable difference from the rougher stacking near Ishikawa-mon.
Kanazawa Castle Vol. 2: Kahoku-mon Gate, Sannomaru Plaza & Hashizume-mon — The Reconstructed Front Entrance in 360°
Walk Kanazawa Castle's main approach: Kahoku-mon Gate (reconstructed 2010), Sannomaru Plaza's Kirikomi-hagi stonework, and Hashizume-mon. 360° panoramas and free interior access.
AREA 03 | Kita-no-maru & West Ninomaru

Kita-no-maru & West Ninomaru (Dobashi Gate Ruins, Kitte-mon, Former 6th Brigade HQ)

A quieter northwestern zone. Gate remains and military-era buildings spanning the Edo-to-Meiji transition, with excellent examples of diverse stonework techniques in the ramparts.

Visitor’s note: This section is noticeably quieter than the Ishikawa-mon and Ninomaru areas — most visitors don’t make it this far. The Former 6th Brigade Headquarters is a genuine Meiji-era survivor and looks strikingly different from the white castle architecture: red-brick, western-influenced, and clearly out of place in the best possible way. It’s the most visible reminder that this site was a working military base for decades after the Edo period ended.
Kanazawa Castle Vol. 3: Kita-no-maru & West Ninomaru — Kikko-ishi Stone Walls & Meiji Military HQ in 360°
Kanazawa Castle's quietest zone: hexagonal Kikko-ishi stonework at Dobashi-mon ruins, the permit-access Kitte-mon Gate, and the Meiji-era 6th Brigade Headquarters. 360° panoramas throughout.
AREA 04 | Ninomaru Core

Ninomaru Core (Palace Site, Gokuraku Bridge, Long Storehouses)

The political heart where the lord’s palace once stood. The aesthetic centre of Kanazawa Castle, home to the Hishi Yagura, Gojikken Nagaya, Sanjikken Nagaya, and the graceful Gokuraku-bashi bridge.

Visitor’s note: The Hishi Yagura and Gojikken Nagaya (both reconstructed 2001) are the visual centrepiece of the park. What surprised me on the actual visit was how much the “Kikko-ishi” (hexagonal stone) technique stands out on the walls here. Look at the stone courses to the left as you face the Nagaya: the hexagonal shapes are intentional and distinct from anything you’ll see at other Japanese castles. The interior of the Nagaya is worth the ¥320 fee — the timber framing and the view from the upper level are genuinely impressive.
Kanazawa Castle Vol. 4: Ninomaru Core — Hishi Yagura, Long Storehouses & Palace Site in 360°
Kanazawa Castle's visual centrepiece: Hishi Yagura turret and 90m Gojikken Nagaya storehouse (reconstructed 2001, paid interior). Ninomaru Palace site, Gokuraku Bridge, and 360° panoramas.
AREA 05 | Honmaru & Higashi-no-maru

Honmaru & Higashi-no-maru (Honmaru Grounds, Turret Sites, Tsurumaru Warehouse)

The topmost defensive core of the castle. The Inui, Tatsumi, and Ushitora turret sites, plus the Tsurumaru Warehouse — a rare genuine Edo survivor. Views over the old castle town are superb.

Visitor’s note: The Honmaru area feels genuinely different from the rest of the park — quieter, more open, with a sense of being at the original core of the castle. The turret sites (Inui, Tatsumi, Ushitora) are marked foundations rather than standing structures, but standing on the Honmaru plateau and looking back toward the Ninomaru and the city gives you a clear sense of why this position was chosen. The Tsurumaru Warehouse is easy to miss — but as one of the few genuinely original Edo-period structures in the park, it’s worth a closer look than most visitors give it.
Kanazawa Castle Vol. 5: Honmaru — 1590s Nozura-zumi Stone Walls, Turret Sites & Tsurumaru Storehouse in 360°
Climb to Kanazawa Castle's inner sanctum: the Honmaru plateau with 1590s Nozura-zumi stonework at Inui and Ushitora turret sites, the Edo-period Tsurumaru Storehouse, and panoramic city views.
AREA 06 | Western Bailey & Outer Enclosure

Western Bailey & Outer Enclosure (Gyokusen’inmaru Garden & Nezumita-mon)

A culturally rich zone spreading west of the castle. The Gyokusen’inmaru Garden is a multi-layered pond-stroll garden where stonework and flowing water create depth and drama. The adjacent Nezumita-mon Gate & Bridge (2020) showcase striking black namako plaster walls.

Visitor’s note: Gyokusen’inmaru Garden (restored 2015, ¥320 admission) is the most undervisited part of the castle park. Even on a busy day, the garden itself tends to be quiet. The multi-level design means you’re looking at the stonework and water features from different heights as you walk, creating a very different experience from a flat garden. The Nezumita-mon Bridge at the western exit has the most striking exterior of any structure in the park — the black namako plaster walls photograph very well in late afternoon light.
Kanazawa Castle Vol. 6: Gyokusen’inmaru Garden & Nezumita-mon — The West Bailey & Night Illumination in 360°
Kanazawa Castle's most peaceful zone: Gyokusen'inmaru Garden (restored 2015, ¥320), Nezumita-mon Bridge (rebuilt 2020), and night illumination tips. 360° panoramas included. Personally visited.

Planning Your Visit: How Long, Which Areas, and What to Skip

Based on a personal visit covering all six areas, here is an honest time and priority breakdown — the kind of practical detail that tends to be missing from official sources.

Start at Ishikawa-mon Gate → Sannomaru / Kahoku-mon → Kita-no-maru → Ninomaru (Hishi Yagura) → Honmaru → Gyokusen’inmaru Garden → exit via Nezumita-mon. This is the complete clockwise loop and covers every significant structure in the park.

Ishikawa-mon Gate → Kahoku-mon approach → Hishi Yagura & Gojikken Nagaya → exit. You will miss the Honmaru plateau views and the garden, but you will see the architectural centrepieces. Skip the Kita-no-maru area if pressed for time — it is the most commonly skipped section by first-time visitors.

The stone walls are worth seeing in rain — the colours deepen and contrast improves significantly for photography. The Nagaya interior (¥320) provides covered shelter while still delivering architectural interest. Gyokusen’inmaru Garden in rain is atmospheric rather than inconvenient.

Spring (late March–early May): Cherry blossoms along the Sannomaru plaza approach — one of Kanazawa’s most photographed scenes.

Autumn (mid-October–mid-November): Foliage around Gyokusen’inmaru Garden. Crowds are manageable on weekday mornings.

Winter: Illumination events run seasonally; the white castle walls photograph particularly well under artificial light against a dark sky.

Summer mornings (before 9 AM): The least crowded time for architectural photography throughout the year.

Kanazawa Castle and Kenrokuen Garden are directly adjacent, connected via Ishikawa-mon Gate. A combined visit takes 3–4 hours. The recommended sequence: start at Kanazawa Castle (grounds open 7:00 AM, before Kenrokuen crowds arrive), complete the 6-area loop, then cross through Ishikawa-mon into Kenrokuen mid-morning. This avoids the worst of the tour group congestion in Kenrokuen between 10 AM and noon.

The Nagaya interior is worth the fee for architecture enthusiasts. The timber framing inside is impressive, and the upper-level view toward the Ninomaru plaza is the best elevated viewpoint available in the park. The Gyokusen’inmaru Garden (separate ¥320) is exceptional for visitors who enjoy Japanese strolling gardens — it is also the least crowded part of the entire park, even on busy days. Budget an additional 30 minutes for each paid area.


Frequently Asked Questions

The grounds are free to enter. The inner buildings (Hishi Yagura and Gojikken Nagaya) and Gyokusen’inmaru Garden each cost ¥320 for adults. Based on a personal visit, both paid areas are worth the fee: the Nagaya interior shows the timber construction in detail, and Gyokusen’inmaru is consistently the quietest part of the entire park — even on busy days.
Allow 90–120 minutes for the full 6-area route at a comfortable pace. If you have 45–60 minutes, focus on Ishikawa-mon Gate, the Ninomaru area (Hishi Yagura), and the Kahoku-mon approach. The Honmaru and Western Bailey can be skipped if time is short, though the Honmaru plateau view is worth the detour if possible.
From JR Tokyo Station, take the Hokuriku Shinkansen to JR Kanazawa Station (approx. 2 hr 30 min). From Kanazawa Station East Exit, take the Kanazawa Loop Bus or Kenrokuen Shuttle — about 20 minutes to the Kanazawa Castle / Kenrokuen-shita stop. IC cards (Suica, ICOCA) are accepted on most routes.
Maeda Toshiie entered Kanazawa Castle in 1583 and established it as the seat of the Kaga Domain, one of the wealthiest in Japan outside the Tokugawa shogunate. Under Toshiie and his successors, the castle and castle town were developed over nearly 300 years. The Maeda clan’s patronage of arts and crafts — including lacquerware, pottery, and Noh theatre — shaped Kanazawa’s identity well into the modern era.
Spring (late March to early May) brings cherry blossoms along the Sannomaru plaza — one of Kanazawa’s most photographed seasonal scenes. Autumn (mid-October to mid-November) offers foliage around Gyokusen’inmaru Garden. Winter illumination events run seasonally, and the white castle walls photograph particularly well under artificial light. Summer mornings before 9 AM are the least crowded time year-round.
Yes. Ishikawa-mon Gate was rebuilt in 1788 and survives intact as a National Important Cultural Property. It is one of only two Edo-period structures still standing in the castle park — the other is the Tsurumaru Warehouse. The gate’s masugata (box-shaped) defensive layout, lead-tiled roof, and namako plaster walls are all original features from the Edo period.
Yes. Kanazawa Castle (Kanazawa-jo Ato) is designated as a nationally important historic site by the Japanese government. Ishikawa Prefecture has been conducting an ongoing restoration project since the 1990s, reconstructing the Kahoku-mon Gate (2010), Hishi Yagura and Gojikken Nagaya (2001), and Nezumita-mon Bridge (2020), with further restorations planned.
Yes — the two sites are directly adjacent, connected via Ishikawa-mon Gate. A combined visit takes 3–4 hours. The recommended approach from personal experience: start at Kanazawa Castle (grounds open 7:00 AM) before Kenrokuen crowds arrive, complete the 6-area castle loop, then cross into Kenrokuen mid-morning to avoid the worst of the tour group congestion between 10 AM and noon.
Kanazawa Castle Park’s night illumination events are held seasonally — primarily during the spring cherry blossom season and autumn foliage season. Exact dates and hours vary each year. Check the official Kanazawa Castle Park website before planning a night visit. The white castle walls and lead-tiled roofs are particularly striking under artificial illumination.
Kanazawa Castle displays three distinct stone-stacking techniques on the same walking route: rough Nozurazumi near Ishikawa-mon Gate, precision-fit Kirikomi-hagi along the Kahoku-mon approach, and hexagonal Kikko-ishi at the Ninomaru walls. No other Japanese castle site shows all three techniques in such close proximity — and the differences are visible to the naked eye once you know to look for them.
The main areas — Sannomaru Plaza, Ninomaru Plaza, and most paved pathways — are generally accessible for wheelchairs and strollers. The Honmaru area has some uneven stone paving. The interior of the Hishi Yagura and Gojikken Nagaya (paid area) involves staircases and may not be fully accessible. Confirm accessibility details with the park office or the official website before visiting.

Maeda Toshiie — Historical Sites Index

Maeda Toshiie: Travel Guide: Historic Sites Across Japan
Maeda Toshiie served Nobunaga and Hideyoshi, founded the Kaga Domain, and helped hold Tokugawa Ieyasu in check. Learn his story and where to visit.

Back to Main Page

Japan’s Samurai History, Castle Visits & Battlefield Guides — All Researched on the Ground
On-site guides to Japan's samurai castles and battlefields — with honest notes on what's original and what's reconstructed. Browse by area or warlord.

※ Information on this page is based on a visit made in October 2025. Opening hours, admission fees, and access details are subject to change. Please confirm with the official Kanazawa Castle Park website or on-site before visiting.

※ Admission fees for the inner buildings (Hishi Yagura / Gojikken Nagaya) and Gyokusen’inmaru Garden should be confirmed separately.

comment